When a state medical board disciplines a physician, the assumed cause is usually misconduct. New research from the Philadelphia-based American Board of Internal Medicine suggests that assumption misses much of the picture.
Gaps in medical knowledge, such as prescribing inappropriate medications, incorrectly interpreting imaging studies or ordering an unnecessary high-risk procedure, played a role in 52.3% of the 558 physician disciplinary actions ABIM researchers reviewed, according to the study published Oct. 27 in the Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions.
“When people hear that a doctor has faced disciplinary action, they may think of misconduct or unprofessional behavior; they may not think about gaps in what a doctor knows,” lead author Lauren Duhigg, senior research associate at ABIM, said in a Nov. 16 news release.
Researchers used publicly available state medical board records to examine disciplinary actions from 2011 to 2022 involving California physicians with an ABIM identification number. California was chosen because it has the largest number of active physicians in the U.S. and its licensing board publishes detailed descriptions of disciplinary actions, which can range from a public reprimand or probation to license revocation.
The team also analyzed certification exam performance for 239 of the disciplined physicians who first took the ABIM certification exam between 1996 and 2022. Among physicians disciplined for knowledge gaps, 66.7% passed the ABIM Internal Medicine Certification Exam on their first attempt, compared with 78% of those disciplined for other reasons, such as DUI and fraud convictions or inappropriate relationships with patients.
“Our findings suggest medical knowledge deficits may play a larger role in physician disciplinary actions than many people realize, and these gaps have the potential to directly impact patient care,” Ms. Duhigg said.
The observational study builds on earlier ABIM research, published in 2018, linking Maintenance of Certification exam performance to discipline. Physicians who did not pass the MOC exam within 10 years of board certification, including those who never took it, had more than twice the rate of disciplinary actions as those who passed, and higher MOC scores were associated with fewer disciplinary actions, according to the release. ABIM administers both the certification and MOC exams.
“Medicine changes continuously, and keeping pace with new evidence and standards of care is essential to patient safety,” said co-author Lorna Lynn, MD, senior vice president for health equity and medical assessment engagement at ABIM.
“Doctors can continue learning throughout their careers, and the association between exam performance and knowledge-related disciplinary actions points to the potential for assessment to identify and address gaps before they may place patients at risk,” Dr. Lynn said.
At the Becker’s 32nd Annual Meeting: The Business and Operations of ASCs, taking place October 29-31 in Chicago, ASC leaders, surgeons and healthcare executives will explore strategies to drive growth, enhance operational performance, navigate reimbursement challenges and prepare for the future of ambulatory surgery. Apply for complimentary registration now.
