An orthopedic spine surgeon said Medicare’s 2027 payment changes reward hospitals at the expense of independent practices and will push more physicians into employed models.
The 2027 physician fee schedule, finalized Nov. 4, cuts the conversion factor 2.31% to $32.63 for physicians not in a qualifying advanced alternative payment model. Most of that cut reflects the expiration of a one-time 2.5% increase Congress approved for 2026. The rule also keeps the 2.5% “efficiency adjustment” to work relative value units for non-time-based services, which took effect in 2026. It phases out the indirect practice cost index over 2027 and 2028 and replaces it with a stabilizer meant to limit annual swings in practice expense values. CMS said the index ties practice expense values to specialty survey data from 2007 or earlier.
Meanwhile, under the separate outpatient rule finalized the same day, hospital outpatient and ASC payment rates rise 2.3% in 2027 for facilities that meet quality reporting requirements. However, the ASC weight scalar turns that update into a pay cut for half of the 30 procedures that bring ASCs the most Medicare dollars.
Michael Gallizzi, MD, a robotic and endoscopic spine surgeon at The Steadman Clinic in Vail, Colo., said the practice cost adjustment helped offset mandates that raised overhead, including electronic medical records, documentation requirements and IT costs.
“They were trying to say, ‘OK, we’re going to give this little kicker just to sort of level it out,’” Dr. Gallizzi told Becker’s. “Like, we’re asking you to do more, but we’re kind of giving you a little more just to try and make sure that it’s not going in the wrong direction.”
Without that offset, he said, practices have little reason to invest. “Why are you going to invest in your practice and start using more money with less revenue to fix other issues?”
Dr. Gallizzi said the payment changes favor facilities over the physicians who bring in their business.
“Essentially what they’re doing is they’re rewarding hospitals and they’re hurting independent practices,” he said. “ASCs and hospitals’ reimbursement went up, physicians’ reimbursement went down.”
Thomas Tsai, MD, medical director for health policy research at the American College of Surgeons, previously told Becker’s that the gap is built into the payment system. The physician fee schedule must stay budget neutral, while facility payments increase each year.
“Is that the healthcare system that we wanted to design, where we reward buildings and facilities and systems more than the people who are providing the care for patients?” said Dr. Tsai, a general surgeon at Boston-based Brigham and Women’s Hospital.
If practice expenses keep rising without an offset, Dr. Gallizzi said, physicians face two paths. One is cash-pay practice, which he said only a small share of physicians can run successfully. The other is academic or hospital employment.
Hospitals are willing to absorb those physicians because physicians generate nearly all hospital revenue, he said. For example, he said, a primary care physician who spots an arrhythmia on an EKG sends the patient to a hospital for a cardiac catheterization and CT scan. A surgeon who evaluates a patient books a case that generates revenue for preoperative clearance, anesthesia, OR time, nursing, physical therapy and pharmacy.
“All that revenue that is generated cannot start without a physician,” Dr. Gallizzi said.
Other surgeons have described similar pressure. Charles Taunt, DO, a hip and knee replacement surgeon at Michigan Orthopedic Center in Lansing, Mich., previously told Becker’s that his practice’s physician partners have absorbed recent Medicare reductions by taking pay cuts, while staff wages, health insurance and supply costs rose. He said hospitals can employ surgeons at little or no margin because the surgeons’ orders make up the difference.
“The hospital is OK employing surgeons as sort of an extremely low margin or even loss leader because they’re making all this up on all their imaging and lab and facility fees,” Dr. Taunt said.
Rick Snyder, MD, president of Dallas-based cardiology practice HeartPlace, previously told Becker’s that older physicians in his specialty face the same choice. He estimated 27.5% of cardiologists are 61 or older and said many will retire or sell instead of absorbing more cuts.
“We almost have the perfect storm for consolidating physicians in a site of care that is the least affordable for patients,” Dr. Snyder said.
Dr. Gallizzi said the long-term risk is a thinner physician workforce as older surgeons retire.
“Once all those senior guys, kind of in their 60s to 70s, are all done … there’s going to be no one to fill that void,” he said. “That just decreases access, increases waits.”
